November 3, 2026

A 20% market decline in the first year of retirement can have a much greater effect on a portfolio than the same decline years later.
The reason is sequence-of-returns risk. Once withdrawals begin, the order of investment returns matters. An early loss can reduce the amount left invested while a retiree is still drawing money for living expenses. Any recovery that follows then starts from a smaller balance.
To make the effect easier to see, this article follows a Florida resident who retires at age 65 with a $2 million investment portfolio and plans to withdraw $100,000 in the first year. The withdrawal rises by 2.5% each year to illustrate increasing living costs.
If a $2 million portfolio falls 20%, it drops to $1.6 million.
If $100,000 is then withdrawn for living expenses, $1.5 million remains invested.
A portfolio that falls from $2 million to $1.6 million needs a 25% gain to return to $2 million. After the $100,000 withdrawal reduces the balance to $1.5 million, the portfolio would need a 33.3% gain to return to the original $2 million balance, assuming no further withdrawals.
The withdrawal did not create the market loss. It increased the recovery hurdle by reducing the amount still invested after the decline.
Timing matters because withdrawals can make the order of investment returns affect how much money remains invested over time.
Two retirees can experience the same annual returns over 25 years and still finish with very different portfolio balances if those returns occur in a different order while withdrawals are being taken.
To isolate that effect, this model compares two scenarios:
Scenario A: The portfolio falls 20% in Year 1.
Scenario B: The same 20% decline occurs in Year 10.
Both scenarios start with $2 million, use the same 25 annual returns, and follow the same withdrawal schedule. Only the order of the first 10 returns changes.
| Year | 20% Decline in Year 1 | 20% Decline in Year 10 |
| End of Year 1 | $1,500,000 | $2,140,000 |
| End of Year 2 | $1,577,500 | $2,208,700 |
| End of Year 5 | $1,639,480 | $2,575,788 |
| End of Year 10 | $1,812,615 | $2,219,105 |
| End of Year 20 | $1,324,747 | $2,051,857 |
| End of Year 25 | $863,857 | $1,873,514 |
After 25 years, the later-loss scenario finishes with about $1.01 million more.
The difference is not caused by a different set of returns. Both scenarios use the same 25 annual return figures and the same withdrawal schedule. The difference comes from when the 20% decline occurs relative to those withdrawals.
An early decline reduces the portfolio before many years of retirement spending have occurred. A later decline occurs after the portfolio has had more time to grow while supporting the same withdrawal schedule.
Removing withdrawals from the model shows why sequence-of-returns risk becomes more important once retirement income begins.
Starting with $2 million and applying the same 25 annual returns, both return sequences finish at approximately $8.60 million when no withdrawals are taken.
That happens because the same set of annual returns produces the same ending value regardless of their order when no money is being removed from the portfolio.
Once withdrawals begin, the result changes.
That is the key distinction: return order matters much more when market gains and losses are occurring at the same time money is leaving the portfolio.
A retiree who can rely on other income or reserves for part of their spending may need to withdraw less from investments after a market decline.
In this scenario, the portfolio still falls 20% in Year 1. Planned household spending begins at $100,000 and rises by 2.5% each year, but only 70% of that spending comes from the investment portfolio during the first two years.
That means $70,000 is withdrawn in Year 1 and $71,750 in Year 2. Beginning in Year 3, the original inflation-adjusted withdrawal schedule resumes.
Under these assumptions, reducing portfolio withdrawals for the first two years leaves about $309,000 more in the portfolio by Year 25.
| Year | Full Planned Withdrawal From Portfolio | Reduced Portfolio Withdrawal in Years 1 and 2 |
| End of Year 1 | $1,500,000 | $1,530,000 |
| End of Year 2 | $1,577,500 | $1,641,850 |
| End of Year 5 | $1,639,480 | $1,720,514 |
| End of Year 10 | $1,812,615 | $1,936,992 |
| End of Year 20 | $1,324,747 | $1,547,228 |
| End of Year 25 | $863,857 | $1,172,792 |
The difference develops over time because more money remains invested during the years immediately following the decline.
That does not mean reducing withdrawals is appropriate for every retiree. Some households may have Social Security, pension income, cash reserves, or other resources available, while others may depend more heavily on investment distributions.
The comparison shows how the amount withdrawn soon after a market decline can influence what remains invested for later years.
The same 20% first-year decline can produce very different outcomes depending on how much a household needs to withdraw from the portfolio.
To test that relationship, we kept the $2 million starting balance, the same 25-year return sequence, and the same 2.5% annual increase in withdrawals. The only change was the first-year withdrawal.
As the starting withdrawal rises from 4% to 6% of the portfolio, the effect of an early market decline becomes much more severe.
| First-Year Withdrawal | Starting Withdrawal Rate | 20% Decline in Year 1 | 20% Decline in Year 10 |
| $80,000 | 4% | $2,411,709 after 25 years | $3,219,434 after 25 years |
| $100,000 | 5% | $863,857 after 25 years | $1,873,514 after 25 years |
| $120,000 | 6% | Portfolio depleted during Year 22 | $527,593 after 25 years |
At a $120,000 first-year withdrawal, the portfolio experiencing the 20% decline in Year 1 runs out of money during Year 22. When the same decline occurs in Year 10, about $528,000 remains at the end of Year 25.
The comparison shows that sequence-of-returns risk cannot be evaluated by looking at the market decline alone. How much income a household needs from the portfolio can materially change the long-term result.
These figures do not establish a withdrawal rate that is appropriate for any individual household. Retirement income needs, other sources of income, taxes, inflation, portfolio structure, and time horizon can all affect the outcome.
Not by itself.
A 20% decline tells us what happened to the market value of the assets exposed to that decline. It does not tell us whether a household can continue supporting its retirement spending.
The outcome can also depend on:
The withdrawal analysis above illustrates why those differences matter. Under the same 20% first-year decline and the same return sequence, changing how much income must come from the portfolio produces very different long-term results.
For a Florida resident entering retirement, the important question is therefore not simply, “How much did the market fall?” It is also, “How much does my retirement plan depend on withdrawing money from the portfolio while it is down?”
A market decline should be evaluated together with spending needs, other income sources, and the amount of time the portfolio may need to support retirement.
Other income sources and available reserves can reduce how much a retiree needs to withdraw from investments after a market decline.
Social Security, pension income, cash reserves, short-term fixed-income assets, and other household resources can all affect how much retirement spending must come from the investment portfolio.
That does not mean one source should automatically be used before another. Taxes, portfolio structure, income needs, and personal circumstances can affect that decision.
For retirement planning, the broader question is:
How much of the household’s spending must come from assets that have just declined in value?
The more spending that must be funded from a depressed portfolio, the greater the potential pressure from withdrawals while the portfolio is trying to recover.
That is why retirement income planning involves more than determining how much a portfolio may earn. It also involves understanding where spending will come from when markets are down.
Inflation can increase the pressure on a retirement portfolio because living expenses may continue rising while the portfolio is still recovering from early losses.
The model assumes withdrawals increase by 2.5% each year. Under that assumption, a $100,000 first-year withdrawal grows to roughly $160,000 by Year 20 and more than $180,000 by Year 25.
If living costs rise while the portfolio is recovering, progressively more money may need to be withdrawn to support the same level of spending.
Higher inflation than the model assumes would increase that pressure. Lower inflation would reduce it.
This is why sequence-of-returns risk is not only about when market losses occur. The amount a retiree needs to withdraw in the years that follow can also shape the long-term outcome.
Someone approaching retirement should test how the plan responds if weak returns arrive early, withdrawals continue, inflation rises, or the downturn lasts longer than expected.
Useful questions include:
These questions turn sequence-of-returns risk from an abstract investment concept into a retirement cash-flow problem that can be tested before retirement begins.
The effect of a market decline in retirement depends on more than the size of the loss. When the decline occurs, how much is being withdrawn, and how much spending depends on the portfolio can all change the long-term outcome.
The examples in this article are intended to show how market returns and retirement withdrawals can interact over time.
Yes, but its effect changes once withdrawals begin.
Someone who is still working and contributing to investments may be able to continue buying through a market decline. A retiree drawing income from the portfolio is removing money at the same time, which can make an early loss harder to recover from.
No.
A diversified portfolio may spread exposure across different types of assets, but it cannot remove the possibility of negative returns or the effect of withdrawals during periods when portfolio values are down.
Asset allocation can influence how much of the portfolio is exposed to different risks, but sequence risk still needs to be considered when retirement income depends on invested assets.
Social Security can reduce the amount a household needs to withdraw from investments because it provides income outside the investment portfolio.
The effect depends on the household’s benefit amount, claiming decision, spending needs, taxes, and other income sources.
Yes.
If expenses rise while a portfolio is recovering from early losses, the retiree may need larger withdrawals over time. In this model, withdrawals increase by 2.5% each year specifically to illustrate that pressure.
No.
The market decline is only one input. Withdrawal needs, other income, taxes, inflation, asset allocation, time horizon, and future returns all affect the result.
This article uses a hypothetical illustration designed to explain sequence-of-returns risk. It is not a forecast and does not represent the performance of a specific investment portfolio.
The base model assumes:
The early-loss return sequence is:
| Year | Hypothetical Annual Return |
| 1 | -20% |
| 2 | 12% |
| 3 | 8% |
| 4 | 10% |
| 5 | 6% |
| 6 | 14% |
| 7 | 4% |
| 8 | 9% |
| 9 | 7% |
| 10 | 11% |
| 11 | 5% |
| 12 | 8% |
| 13 | -6% |
| 14 | 13% |
| 15 | 6% |
| 16 | 9% |
| 17 | 4% |
| 18 | 10% |
| 19 | 7% |
| 20 | 5% |
| 21 | 8% |
| 22 | 6% |
| 23 | 9% |
| 24 | 4% |
| 25 | 7% |
The later-loss scenario uses the same annual returns but moves the -20% return to Year 10 and shifts the positive returns that originally appeared in Years 2 through 10 forward by one year.
Because both scenarios use the same 25 returns, they have the same compound annual growth rate before withdrawals, approximately 6.0%. Only the order changes.
The reduced-withdrawal scenario assumes that 70% of planned spending is withdrawn from the modeled portfolio in Years 1 and 2, with the remaining 30% coming from resources outside the model. The original withdrawal schedule resumes in Year 3.
The withdrawal-sensitivity comparison uses first-year withdrawals of $80,000, $100,000, and $120,000, each increasing by 2.5% annually.
The model applies one annual return before one annual withdrawal. Real portfolios change in value throughout the year, and retirees may take withdrawals monthly or at other intervals. That means actual results can differ even when annual return figures appear similar.
Real retirement outcomes may also differ because of taxes, fees, changing spending, Social Security, pensions, health costs, portfolio changes, inflation, and future market conditions.
Landsberg Bennett Private Wealth Management works with individuals and families on financial planning, retirement planning, and investment management based on their circumstances.
Disclaimer:
The examples and portfolio values in this article are hypothetical and are provided solely to demonstrate how the timing of investment returns and withdrawals can affect retirement outcomes. They do not represent actual client results, the performance of any investment strategy, or expected future returns.
Investing involves risk, including the possible loss of principal, and no investment process or strategy is guaranteed to be profitable. Past performance does not guarantee future results, and any investments mentioned may not be suitable for all investors. Hypothetical examples are for illustrative purposes only, do not represent actual results, and actual results and individual experiences may differ.
This material is for general informational and educational purposes only. It is not individualized investment, tax, legal or insurance advice, or a recommendation to buy or sell any security or insurance product. Consult qualified professionals regarding your individual circumstances. Views expressed are solely those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the views of Hightower Advisors, LLC or any of its affiliates.
All information referenced is current as of the publication date and may change without notice. Although obtained from sources believed to be reliable, Hightower Advisors, LLC, and their respective affiliates do not guarantee its accuracy or completeness. References or links to third-party content do not constitute an endorsement of any third party or its products, services, or views. Click here for definitions of and disclosures specific to commonly used terms.
Landsberg Bennett Private Wealth Management is a group comprised of investment professionals associated, and/or registered, with Hightower Advisors, LLC, an SEC registered investment advisor. Some investment professionals may also be registered with Hightower Securities, LLC, member FINRA and SIPC.